Declaring the allotment of spectrum as unconstitutional and arbitrary, the court quashed all 122 licences issued in 2008 by the then minister for communications and it, a. Raja, and senior journalists, politicians, and corporate houses, taped by the indian income tax department in 200809. At present the 2 g spectrum scam is the hot case going on in indian political stage. In 2008 the supreme court of india revoked the 2g spectrum licences issued to many local and international companies because of major violations in the granting procedure by the telecom ministry. Subramanian swamy, a former union cabinet minister, a harvardeducated ec. Former telecom minister a raja, one of the accused in the 2g spectrum scam cases, at patiala house courts in new delhi on tuesday. From scandal to acquittal, the story in 10 numbers from zero to rs 1. The 2g spectrum case was an alleged scam that the politicians and private officials under the united progressive alliance coalition government in india were accused of committing. Most of us know the following with reference to the 2 g spectrum scam. The indian telecom sector had witnessed unparalleled growth since the dawn of the new millennium, attracting the attention of indian as well as global telecom companies. The central bureau of investigation cbi files a first information report fir against unidentified officials of the department of telecommunications on the 2g spectrum airwaves auction, based on a reference. Cag report on 2g scam here are some of the points made by the cag report. Raja in the corruption involved in the 2g spectrum scam on 27 november,2010.
In shock verdict, court acquits a raja, kanimozhi and other accused. Dec 21, 2017 a special cbi court on thursday acquitted all 18 accused including a raja and k kanimozhi in 2g spectrum allocation case. The verdict in the 2g spectrum scam case has been delivered by a special cbi court, acquitting all accused, including former telecom minister a raja and dmks kanimozhi. The government awarded 122 telecom licenses with 2g spectrum in january 2008 at 2001 rates rs 1,685 crore ignoring the current market value of the spectrum. Former telecom minister a raja, one of the accused in the 2g spectrum scam cases, at patiala house courts in new delhi on.
A special cbi court acquitted all the accused in the 2g scam on december 21. The case was investigated by the central bureau of investigation which filed an 80,000 page chargesheet before the trial court. The nexus between the state and business establishments has been around for a long time, existing across time and space, and instances of it are well documented. In february 2007, hutch sold its 67% equity to vodafone at rs 75,000 cr signaling substantial increase in spectrum. History of 2g 2g spectrum technology was first launched in 1991 in. A brief summary of the status of the 2 g spectrum scam in. Watch this video to know about the independent indias biggest political scam 2g spectrum scandal which led the downfall of upa ii. The 2g spectrum scam in india case study solution, telenors dilemma. It is a widely held belief that this was the beginning of the end of the manmohan singhled upa government.
If you have opted to buy the pdf version of the case study, you will receive a link to download the file, after the transaction is successfully completed. The commonwealth games is an international multisport event involving athletes from the commonwealth of nations. What subramanian swamy, the man who exposed the 2g case. Raja and dmk rajya sabha member kanimozhi in the 2g spectrum allocation case. Mar 11, 20 the 2g scam a short summary posted on march 11, 20 march 11, 20 by theconsiglieres mobile and allied networks work on specific frequencies allotted to each operator in a band of frequencies known as a spectrum. Cbi appeal infructuous in view of new antigraft law, a raja tells hc 27 jan, 2020, 10. This piece is being republished from the quints archives in light of the verdict in the 2g spectrum scam on thursday, 21 december, which acquitted all 17 accused in the case.
Case study on the supreme court ruling on the 2g spectrum. Dec 22, 2017 scroll if there was no 2g scam, why did the supreme court cancel 122 spectrum licences in 2012. The 2g spectrum scam in india case solution, in 2008, the supreme court of india, the 2g spectrum licenses issued to many local and international companies because of the. The 2g spectrum scam in india excel file, subjects covered strategy by sanjeev prashar, adeshwar raja balaji pras, v.
However, in early 2011, several indian telecom companies were under the scanner for alleged irregularities in grant of licenses and spectrum allocation. Performance audit report on the issue of licences and allocation of 2g spectrum pdf. A special court is likely to decide the fate of former telecom minister a raja, dmk mp kanimozhi and several others in the muchanticipated 2g spectrum allocation scam cases. Successful applications for 3g licences committed themselves to participating in any redistribution of spectrum across operators linked to refarming of their 2g licences. Cbi has raided a rajas house, not once, not twice, but innumerable times. The commonwealth games scam involved large scale misappropriation of money during. The discussion around the reactions to the 2g spectrum scam. What happened actually in the commonwealth games 2010 scam. Auditing2g spectrum scam 1 2g spectrum scam a case. In this 2g spectrum scam many government officials are involved for illegally undercharging frequency allocation for the mobile telephonic companies. The 2g spectrum scam in india xls file, telenors dilemma. So subramanian swamy decided to file a case against former union minister a. The 2g spectrum scam in india case solution, in 2008, the supreme court of india, the 2g spectrum licenses issued to many local and international companies because of the great injuries ministry revok.
In a draft report issued in march 2014, the comptroller and auditor general of india cag office accused the government of india of allocating coal blocks in an inefficient manner during the period. It was claimed that the magnitude of the scam was 2,867,800,000,000 rupee. The cpim maintained that it was well established by the comptroller and auditor general cag that the allocation of 2g spectrum had caused a big loss of rs. Why the supreme court cancel 122 spectrum licences. A special cbi court on thursday acquitted all 18 accused including a raja and k kanimozhi in 2g spectrum allocation case.
Quashing of 2g spectrum licences on february 20, 2012, the supreme court of india delivered a judgement on a pil directly related to the 2g spectrum scam. The tapes were leaked out to the press, and were eventually published by some media outlets and shown by television. The 2g spectrum scam in india financial system security. The 2g spectrum scam in india case study solution, in 2008 the supreme court of india has canceled the 2g spectrum licenses with many local and international companies because of serious irregularities in t.
In the 2g spectrum scam case, instead of providing valuable insights, the media is trying to become the judiciary. The scam came to light almost seven years ago when the comptroller and. Spectralefficiency of 3g and 2g are comparable, and therefore, concluded that 3g price should be the currentpricefor 2g spectrum in 2010. In an unprecedented development, all accused in the three cases related to the 2g spectrum allocation scam have been acquitted by a special cbi cour.
The union government of that time was accused of undercharging mobile telephone companies for frequency allocation licenses, which they used. In normal basic telephone service, a pair of wires is used for communication. In january 2011, the supreme court of india issued notices to 11 private. In the 2g scam, almost all of the entire media and nation has put the name of mr a. For a quick understanding of the scam, read this shorter explainer by shalini singh, reporter who broke the story. Cong claims vindication, bjp says its no badge of honour the verdict in the 2g spectrum scam case has been delivered by a special. To the share scams and financial frauds in india and abroad during the. Oct 25, 2017 insert commentsa special court deferred hearing in the 2g spectrum scam cases in which former telecom minister a raja and dmk mp kanimozhi are among the ac. As already mentioned, the licenses on 2g spectrum was issued at a throwaway prices in which no rules and procedures were followed while giving away to private telecom players in 2008 which. After the 1991 share scam in india and why despite such measures. The 2g spectrum scandal involved officials in the government of india illegally undercharging mobile telephone companies for frequency allocation licenses, which they would use to create 2g subscriptions for cell phones. The 2g spectrum scam in india case analysis, telenors dilemma.
History of 2g 2g spectrum technology was first launched in 1991 in finland only in the gsm mobile phones but this is not the latest technology that we are using. Media coverage of the report and license allocation, hyped as the 2g scam, was followed by public outrage and protests. Former telecom minister a raja was acquitted in 2g spectrum allocation scam case today. Cbi registers case related to alleged irregularities in allocation of 2g spectrum. Former telecom minister a raja and dmk lawmaker kanimozhi have been acquitted in the 2g scam that shook the country in 2011. Presentation on 2g spectrum authorstream presentation. The 2g scam a short summary posted on march 11, 20 march 11, 20 by theconsiglieres mobile and allied networks work on specific frequencies allotted to each operator in a band of frequencies known as a spectrum. Coal allocation scam or coalgate is a major political scandal concerning the indian governments allocation of the nations coal deposits to public sector enterprise pses and private companies. Be it the railroad robber barons in the us, the zaibatsu in japan, the russian oligarchs, or the korean chaebols, they all exemplify smoky backroom dealings and patronage politics. Finland only in the gsm mobile phones but this is not the latest technology that we are using. Dmk mp kanimozhi and several others in the muchanticipated 2g spectrum allocation scam cases. Only when the comptroller and auditor general of india in a report quantified and pegged the scam loss to rs.
First of all, it was miscalculated to be a notional loss, not even a real loss. Dec 21, 2017 former telecom minister andimuthu raja, popularly called a raja, got acquitted in the 2g spectrum scam case today along with 16 others. Raja as the responsible person for the corruption but the actual decision of telecom policy was passed through the cabinet. The 2g spectrum scam in india, if a solution related case solutions. The case was initially referred by the central vigilance commission to the cbi for. A delhi court on thursday acquitted all accused, including former telecom minister a. The government awarded 122 telecom licenses with 2g spectrum in. The case was investigated by the central bureau of investigation. Hindustan times via getty images former telecom minister a raja leaves after a hearing in the 2g spectrum allocation scam case at patiala court on march 16, 2015 in new delhi, india. The comptroller and auditor general cag report on the allotment of 2g spectrum. How would you tell about 2g spectrum scam to a man who has.
Harshad mehta and the billiondollar scam financial system security. The supreme court said that this 2g scam is the mother of all the scams. We are not able to appreciate, in the instant case, the. Bjp leader subramanian swamy, the man who exposed the multicrore 2g spectrum allocation scam, on thursday said the govern. Scribd is the worlds largest social reading and publishing site. Following is the chronology of events on what is believed to be indias biggest scam. A brief summary of the status of the 2 g spectrum scam. The essay sample on 2g scam amount in rupees dwells on its problems, providing a shortened but comprehensive overview of basic facts and arguments related to it.
The comptroller and auditor general cag report on the allotment of 2g spectrum licences, tabled in the lok sabha today, has held. The 2g spectrum scam involved officials and ministers in the government of india illegally undercharging mobile telephony companies for frequency allocation licenses, which they would use to create 2g subscriptions for cell phones. One of the worst affected companies was norways telenor communications company, which was involved with a local company in a joint venture, uninor. Most of us know the following with reference to the 2 gspectrum scam. Cbi appeal infructuous in view of new antigraft law, a raja tells hc. The media has targeted easy scapegoats, revolving their stories around a selected few because even they know that it is difficult for them to target certain big names like the tatas, ambanis and ruias. Rules and procedures flouted while issuing licenses what are the cha. Read the full 1552page verdict a special cbi court pronounced former telecom minister a raja and all other accused in the case as innocent, citing lack of evidence from the prosecution.
As 2g was launched in 1991 so many other technologies overcome it with 2. Since the 3g auctions were held in 2010, but 2g spectrum was given in. The what, why, how and what next of the case involving a raja and kanimozhi india fp staff dec 21, 2017 19. The radia tapes controversy relates to the telephonic conversations between nira radia, a political lobbyist in india, the then indian telecom minister a. The 2g scam is one of the biggest scam till now in india and the highest authority of india supreme court stated that this scam is mother of all the scam till now in india. Raja sold licenses 2g spectrum to a handful of arbitrarily selected 120 out of 575 companies in january 2008 at a bargain basement 2001 price. The 2g spectrum case was an alleged scam that the politicians and private officials under the. Senior advocate abhishek m singhvi, appearing for raja, told the court that the graft charges levelled against. A chronology in 2008, the central government of india granted 122 telecom licenses to various companies in response to 575 applications for licenses. The 2g spectrum scam in india case solution,telenors dilemma. A chronology of what is known to be indias biggest scam while dmk supporters and congress leaders hailed the decision, the bjp appeared standoffish over the courts verdict. The special court has deferred hearing on the final judgment in the cases till december 5.
A timeline of how the case progressed a special court pronounced its final verdict on december 21 in the 2g spectrum allocation scam, acquitting former telecom. Secondgeneration wireless telephone technology 2g is relatively new technology in the field of mobile. Case study on the supreme court ruling on the 2g spectrum scam. Along with kanimozhi and raja, all the other accused in the case including quite a few corporate hotshots were too given a clean chit. France began to think about the process of refarming 2g spectrum as far back as 2001, at the time of its first 3g award. Charge by charge, how the case collapsed wheres the proof of wrongdoing, asked special judge o p saini. Since 3g spectrum is three times more efficient than 2g, the loss is further down to rs. On the 2nd of february 2012, the supreme court of india, in response to a public interest litigation pil, cancelled all 122 telecom licenses granted in 2008 and directed that the spectrum linked with these licenses be. Dec 21, 2017 the judgement relating to the 2g scam case of today has been prima facie examined and it appears that the evidence adduced to substantiate the charges by the prosecution has not been. Harshad mehta and the billiondollar scam asclepius consulting.
1411 1302 936 1126 630 346 925 731 549 1026 51 448 1387 964 967 576 1034 1420 94 529 1486 531 1278 1165 1002 1420 246 1314 187 948 1315 553 879 480